top of page
Search

Can a Non-Executive Non-Independent Director become an Independent Director a few years later?

Oct 27
2 min read

This question comes up repeatedly in boardroom discussions.


👉 Legally, often yes. Practically - especially for listed companies - it is an uphill battle.


There is no blanket prohibition. The individual must, however, meet the independence criteria under Section 149(6) of the Companies Act, 2013 and, for listed entities, Regulation 16 of SEBI LODR.


The real question is not how many years have passed. It is what kept the individual from qualifying earlier, and whether that impediment has genuinely ceased.


🔹 RELATIONSHIPS THAT CAN LAPSE OVER TIME:


▪️ Section 149(6)(e)(i): a three-financial-year test for past KMP or employee positions in the company or its holding, subsidiary or associate. SEBI LODR extends to promoter group companies.


▪️ Section 149(6)(e)(ii): the same test for past roles with the company's auditors, company secretaries in practice or cost auditors. For a legal or consulting firm, it applies only where the firm's transactions with the company reach 10% of its gross turnover.


▪️ Section 149(6)(c): pecuniary relationships (exceeding 10% of total income) over the two preceding financial years and the current year. SEBI LODR applies a "material pecuniary relationship" test under Regulation 16(1)(b)(iv). Both exclude director's remuneration.


🔸 TIME ALONE WILL NOT CURE THESE:


▪️ Promoter: Section 149(6)(b)(i) says "is or was". A former promoter is permanently disqualified. There is no cooling-off.


▪️ Nominee directors cannot be IDs. A director representing a lender, investor or promoter must first cease to be a nominee and must still meet every other test.


▪️ Relationships with promoters or directors, and voting power of 2% or more held with relatives (Section 149(6)(e)(iii)), disqualify until the facts change, e.g. the related director leaves the board or the holding is reduced.


🏛️ LISTED ENTITIES:


Regulation 16 adds its own tests, including promoter-group membership and board interlocks.


đź“‹ WHAT SHOULD THE BOARD DO?


✔️ Identify the original impediment and document how it has ceased.

✔️ Obtain fresh declarations and verify eligibility.

✔️ Treat it as a fresh ID appointment, including shareholder approval under Regulation 25(2A) for listed entities.

✔️ Ensure NRC evaluation and a reasoned Board assessment of integrity, expertise and independence.

✔️ Complete the filing requirements, and applicable disclosures under Regulation 30.


⚖️ Formal eligibility and perceived independence are not the same.


Proxy advisers and institutional investors regularly scrutinise such re-designations, especially where the earlier link was with the promoters (Whirlpool of India, March 2026).


A re-designation should rest on a documented assessment, not merely on passage of time.


đź’¬ Has your Board evaluated such a transition? How did your NRC handle the assessment?


Comments


Post: Blog2_Post
  • LinkedIn

©2026 Sandeep Lakhotia & Associates.

bottom of page